Safety of different surgical modalities for recurrent respiratory papillomatosis resection: A systematic review and meta-analysis

source extracted confidence: high 2026-04-09
#carbon-dioxide #postoperative-complications #papillomavirus-infections #prospective-studies #humans

Safety of different surgical modalities for recurrent respiratory papillomatosis resection: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Liu et al., 2023 | Clin Otolaryngol | Meta Analysis

Citation

Liu Siwei, Wang Jiaqi, Shao Jun. Safety of different surgical modalities for recurrent respiratory papillomatosis resection: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Otolaryngol. 2023-May;48(3):403-413. doi:10.1111/coa.14023

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Currently, the most common surgical modalities used for recurrent respiratory papillomatosis (RRP) resection are microdebrider, carbon dioxide (CO2 ) laser and potassium-titanyl-phosphate (KTP) laser. However, complication rates vary among different surgical modalities and have been controversial in different studies. OBJECTIVE OF REVIEW: This study systematically reviews the available studies which reported intra-operative and post-operative complications, aiming to compare the safety of microdebrider, CO2 laser and KTP laser. TYPE OF REVIEW: Meta-analysis. SEARCH STRATEGY: Seven electronic databases (PubMed/MEDLINE, EMBASE[Ovid], Scopus, Cochrane Library and Web of Science) were searched from inception through 28 April 2022. Randomised controlled, prospective or retrospective observational studies that recorded the complications of three different surgical modalities for RRP resection were included in the meta-analysis. EVALUATION METHOD: Outcomes of interest were intra-operative and post-operative complications, and complication rate was calculated to evaluate the safety of surgical methods. RESULTS: Twenty different studies were included in quantitative synthesis. Only one study compared outcomes of those three kinds of treatment modalities simultaneously, two studies compared microdebrider and CO2 laser, and the remaining studies focussed on only one of three treatments. The weighted average complication rate for microdebrider was 0.03 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.00-0.21), n = 6, for CO2 laser treatment was 0.16 (95% CI 0.09-0.25), n = 14 and for KTP laser treatment was 0.04 (95% CI 0.00-0.14), n = 4. CONCLUSION: The limited evidence demonstrated that CO2 lasers in the surgical treatment of RRP may lead to more surgical complications, and microdebrider and KTP lasers may be safer. However, the heterogeneous data limit any strong comparison of outcomes of different treatment of laryngeal papillomas. Future randomised controlled trials that directly compare the safety of different surgical modalities are needed.

Key Findings

Twenty different studies were included in quantitative synthesis. Only one study compared outcomes of those three kinds of treatment modalities simultaneously, two studies compared microdebrider and CO2 laser, and the remaining studies focussed on only one of three treatments. The weighted average complication rate for microdebrider was 0.03 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.00-0.21), n = 6, for CO2 laser treatment was 0.16 (95% CI 0.09-0.25), n = 14 and for KTP laser treatment was 0.04 (95% CI 0.

Outcomes Measured

  • Requires manual extraction

Population

Field Value
Population See abstract
Sample Size 6
Age Range See abstract
Condition See abstract

MeSH Terms

  • Carbon Dioxide
  • Postoperative Complications
  • Papillomavirus Infections
  • Prospective Studies
  • Humans
  • Laryngeal Neoplasms
  • Retrospective Studies
  • Respiratory Tract Infections

Evidence Classification

  • Level: Meta Analysis
  • Publication Types: Meta-Analysis, Systematic Review, Journal Article
  • Vertical: potassium

Provenance

Source extracted via PubMed E-utilities API on 2026-04-09